Skip to content
Copyright Clearance Center - Copyright & Licensing Experts
  • Get permissions & content
  • Request a demo
  • Get help
  • Log in
    • CCC Marketplace
    • RightFind Enterprise
    • RightFind Navigate
    • RightsLink Permissions
    • Rightsholder Accounts
    • Ringgold Identify Database
    • Institutional Portal
  • Solutions

    • Business
    • Publishing
    • Academia
    • Standards

    Solutions for Business: Overview

    • RightFind Suite Software
      Robust software solutions to fuel scientific research and simplify copyright compliance
    • RightFind Navigate
      Personalized search of scientific content across internal and external data sources
    • RightFind Enterprise
      STM literature management and document delivery
    • RightFind XML
      Licensed article collections for full-text data mining
    • Document Delivery with RightFind
      One-stop journal article ordering and fulfillment
    • RightFind Cite It
      Simplified reference management software
    • CCC Expert View
      Knowledge graphs to ID key opinion leaders
    • Copyright Licensing
      Enterprise-wide content licensing solutions with millions of rights from thousands of publishers
    • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
      Harmonized content collaboration and reuse rights for US-based employees
    • Multinational Copyright License (MCL)
      Extending license coverage to employees around the world
    • Information Services
      Making content and development workflows more discoverable and efficient
    • Deep Search Solutions
      Targeted data gathered, analyzed, and delivered from a range of online sources
    • Reprints & Permissions Services
      Fulfillment of bulk medical/scientific article reprints, ePrints, and permissions
    • Managed Knowledge Services
      Library and information management staffing services
    • CCC Marketplace
      Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in medcomms & business

    Solutions for Publishing: Overview

    • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
      Innovative, metadata-driven solutions to help publishers scale and optimize their transforming business
    • RightsLink for Scientific Communications
      Open Access funding and payment workflow solution
    • OA Intelligence
      AI-enabled data disambiguation, agreement modeling, and analysis software
    • Ringgold Solutions
      Organization persistent identifier (PID) solution and services
    • RightsLink Author Services
      Automated services to expand publication and promotional offerings in author workflows
    • Data Solutions & Services
      Data intelligence and disambiguation solutions and expertise to inform business strategy
    • Ringgold Identify Database
      Leading curated database of organization persistent identifiers (PIDs)
    • Ringgold Audit Service
      Expert data normalization, enrichment and mapping to Ringgold Identify Database
    • Ringgold Validate Service
      On-demand service to create new Ringgold Organization IDs
    • Ringgold Consortium Directory
      Comprehensive database of up-to-date global consortia records
    • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
      Copyright licenses and transactional services to help publishers expand markets and secure copyright permissions
    • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
      Voluntary collective licenses to compensate publishers for the reuse of their content
    • CCC Marketplace
      Transactional copyright permissions to enable content reuse in published materials
    • Get It Now
      Single article fulfillment of publisher content for higher education
    • Document Delivery with RightFind
      Single article fulfillment of publisher content for businesses
    • Reprints Services for Publishers
      Full-service management of bulk article reprints and ePrints business

    Solutions for Academia: Overview

    • Content & Licensing Solutions
      Content search, discovery, licensing, and fulfillment
    • RightFind Curriculum
      Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 curriculum and instruction
    • Annual Copyright License for Student Assessments
      Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 student assessments, item banks, and pre-and post-test materials.
    • Get It Now
      Cost-effective, integrated 24/7 full-text academic article fulfillment from non-subscribed journals
    • Copyright Licensing
      Annual and transactional licensing solutions for the reuse of copyrighted content in academia
    • Annual Copyright License for Higher Education (ACLHE)
      Rights to reuse and share content across your institution
    • CCC Marketplace
      Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in higher education
    • Copyright Education
      Complimentary webcasts and certificate courses to help navigate copyright and content use in education
    • Copyright Essentials for K-12 Certificate Course
      Foundations of copyright law and its impact on K-12 education
    • Copyright 101 for Academia Certificate Course
      Foundations of copyright law and its impact in higher education
  • Resources

    • Resource Library
      Access recordings, customer success stories, white papers, blog posts, and insights by industry experts.
    • Case studies
    • Communities
    • Videos
    • White papers
    • Insights
    • Blog posts
    • Copyright Education
      Learn about copyright protection, international principles, and best practices for licensing.
    • Copyright foundations
    • International copyright
    • Certificate courses
    • Complimentary webcasts
    • Upcoming Events
      Browse our calendar of webcasts, conferences, presentations, and education programs.
    • Webcasts
    • Conferences
    • Copyright education
    • Media Center
      View the latest CCC news, press coverage, and trending posts on the Velocity of Content blog.
    • Velocity of Content blog
    • CCC In the News
    • Press releases
    • Company
      Learn more about our organization, explore career opportunities, and meet the executive team
    • About CCC
    • Careers & Community
    • Executive Leadership
    • Board of Directors
    • International Advancement
    • Partner Program
  • Solutions
  • Business
    • Overview
    • RightFind Suite Software
      • RightFind Suite Software
        Robust software solutions to fuel scientific research and simplify copyright compliance
      • RightFind Navigate
        Personalized search of scientific content across internal and external data sources
      • RightFind Enterprise
        STM literature management and document delivery
      • RightFind XML
        Licensed article collections for full-text data mining
      • Document Delivery with RightFind
        One-stop journal article ordering and fulfillment
      • RightFind Cite It
        Simplified reference management software
      • CCC Expert View
        Knowledge graphs to ID key opinion leaders
    • Copyright Licensing
      • Copyright Licensing
        Enterprise-wide content licensing solutions with millions of rights from thousands of publishers
      • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
        Harmonized content collaboration and reuse rights for US-based employees
      • Multinational Copyright License (MCL)
        Extending license coverage to employees around the world
    • Information Services
      • Information Services
        Making content and development workflows more discoverable and efficient
      • Deep Search Solutions
        Targeted data gathered, analyzed, and delivered from a range of online sources
      • Reprints & Permissions Services
        Fulfillment of bulk medical/scientific article reprints, ePrints, and permissions
      • Managed Knowledge Services
        Library and information management staffing services
      • CCC Marketplace
        Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in medcomms & business
  • Publishing
    • Overview
    • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
      • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
        Innovative, metadata-driven solutions to help publishers scale and optimize their transforming business
      • RightsLink for Scientific Communications
        Open Access funding and payment workflow solution
      • OA Intelligence
        AI-enabled data disambiguation, agreement modeling, and analysis software
      • Ringgold Solutions
        Organization persistent identifier (PID) solution and services
      • RightsLink Author Services
        Automated services to expand publication and promotional offerings in author workflows
    • Data Solutions & Services
      • Data Solutions & Services
        Data intelligence and disambiguation solutions and expertise to inform business strategy
      • Ringgold Identify Database
        Leading curated database of organization persistent identifiers (PIDs)
      • Ringgold Audit Service
        Expert data normalization, enrichment and mapping to Ringgold Identify Database
      • Ringgold Validate Service
        On-demand service to create new Ringgold Organization IDs
      • Ringgold Consortium Directory
        Comprehensive database of up-to-date global consortia records
    • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
      • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
        Copyright licenses and transactional services to help publishers expand markets and secure copyright permissions
      • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
        Voluntary collective licenses to compensate publishers for the reuse of their content
      • CCC Marketplace
        Transactional copyright permissions to enable content reuse in published materials
      • Get It Now
        Single article fulfillment of publisher content for higher education
      • Document Delivery with RightFind
        Single article fulfillment of publisher content for businesses
      • Reprints Services for Publishers
        Full-service management of bulk article reprints and ePrints business
  • Academia
    • Overview
    • Content Solutions
      • Content & Licensing Solutions
        Content search, discovery, licensing, and fulfillment
      • RightFind Curriculum
        Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 curriculum and instruction
      • Annual Copyright License for Student Assessments
        Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 student assessments, item banks, and pre-and post-test materials.
      • Get It Now
        Cost-effective, integrated 24/7 full-text academic article fulfillment from non-subscribed journals
    • Copyright Licensing
      • Copyright Licensing
        Annual and transactional licensing solutions for the reuse of copyrighted content in academia
      • Annual Copyright License for Higher Education (ACLHE)
        Rights to reuse and share content across your institution
      • CCC Marketplace
        Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in higher education
    • Copyright Education
      • Copyright Education
        Complimentary webcasts and certificate courses to help navigate copyright and content use in education
      • Copyright Essentials for K-12 Certificate Course
        Foundations of copyright law and its impact on K-12 education
      • Copyright 101 for Academia Certificate Course
        Foundations of copyright law and its impact in higher education
  • Standards
  • Resources
    • Resource Library
      • Resource Library
        Access recordings, customer success stories, white papers, blog posts, and insights by industry experts.
      • Case studies
      • Communities
      • Videos
      • White papers
      • Insights
      • Blog posts
    • Copyright education
      • Copyright Education
        Learn about copyright protection, international principles, and best practices for licensing.
      • Copyright foundations
      • International copyright
      • Certificate courses
      • Complimentary webcasts
    • Upcoming Events
      • Upcoming Events
        Browse our calendar of webcasts, conferences, presentations, and education programs.
      • Webcasts
      • Conferences
      • Copyright education
    • Media Center
      • Media Center
        View the latest CCC news, press coverage, and trending posts on the Velocity of Content blog.
      • Velocity of Content blog
      • CCC In the News
      • Press releases
  • Company
    • Company
      Learn more about our organization, explore career opportunities, and meet the executive team
    • About CCC
    • Careers & Community
    • Executive Leadership
    • Board of Directors
    • International Advancement
    • Partner Program
  • Get permissions & content
  • Request a demo
  • Get help
  • Log in
    • CCC Marketplace
    • RightFind Enterprise
    • RightFind Navigate
    • RightsLink Permissions
    • Rightsholder Accounts
    • Ringgold Identify Database
    • Institutional Portal

Velocity of Content

Home Blog Research & Development The State of Scholarly Metadata: 2023
Visual representation of "The State of Scholarly Metadata: 2023" study interface

The State of Scholarly Metadata: 2023

By Roy Kaufman, Jamie Carmichael, Jessica Thibodeau
30 May 2023

Share this post
facebooklinkedinmail

This article originally appeared in The Scholarly Kitchen

As scholarly communication rapidly adapts to seismic shifts in open science, technology, and culture, a renewed focus has emerged on metadata and persistent identifiers (PIDs) — about people, places, and objects — as an essential component of a vibrant industry. At the US policy level alone, leveraging metadata to accelerate industry transformation is a common theme across the Nelson Memo and recent Requests for Information from the NIH and the Department of Transportation.

Scholarly research is complex and interconnected; change in one area can spark improvement or deterioration throughout the ecosystem. By way of example, consider the role of PIDs in open access (OA) funding entitlements. OA management platforms rely on metadata elements, particularly organizational PIDs passed from upstream submission and peer review systems, to automate the process of matching manuscripts with potential funding sources. This typically happens at article acceptance, and increasingly at submission, eliminating manual administration for authors as well as supporting publishers, institutions, consortia, and funders in achieving OA at scale.

In order to perform a health check on organizational IDs, in 2021, we reviewed cross-publisher records of institutional affiliation and/or funder data in our OA workflow tool, RightsLink for Scientific Communications. We discovered that 82% of accepted manuscripts included such data, which was an improvement over prior years. However, these statistics masked an ugly truth; namely that in many cases those manuscripts used institutional email domains as a proxy for funding or discount eligibility instead of a PID. And within the 18% that carried no PID, missed funding opportunities created unnecessary work (and payments) for authors, institutions, and publishers to reconcile retroactively.

Even if CCC — either alone, or with its partners and publishers — were able to close these metadata gaps at acceptance of manuscripts, this is late in the process and advantages of PIDs earlier in the research lifecycle would be lost. Solving for metadata gaps would be more effective in upstream systems of record so the tail doesn’t wag the dog. This is precisely why we’ve encouraged the NIH to consider the grant application process as an early opportunity to mandate PIDs and cascade to other systems underpinning the research lifecycle, for example, Current Research Information Systems (CRISs).

But where to start? Let’s face it, PIDs are a wonky topic and we need to communicate to people who are not naturally interested in the intricacies of, e.g., ISNI and Ringgold. But these people will care if they know that lack of PIDs can lead to lack of funding. In order to break this down, we recently talked with dozens of stakeholders and mapped a range of metadata challenges through an OA lens. We built on an existing body of work to visualize the ripple effect of a fragmented metadata supply chain. The result is an interactive report of the research lifecycle designed to offer everyone a deeper understanding of the state of scholarly metadata in 2023. Though the issues are numerous, they are not insurmountable, and much infrastructure exists to support change.

About the State of Scholarly Metadata

Working with Media Growth Strategies, we interviewed representatives from institutions, publishers, funders, researchers, service providers, PID providers, and industry associations to capture a broad view of the current state of metadata and PIDs across the ecosystem. We asked questions such as:

  • Who should create and maintain metadata? Where should it originate?
  • What resources do you invest to create, curate, or maintain various types of metadata?
  • What are your biggest challenges when it comes to metadata management and/or use of PIDs?
  • What are the most critical metadata elements?
  • What’s at stake if these elements don’t persist through scholarly communications?
  • Who should own metadata quality and control?
Interactive "The State of Scholarly Metadata: 2023" visual study
The State of Scholarly Metadata: 2023 visual report depicts economic and social impact of the fragmented metadata supply chain across the ecosystem.

Here is what they said about the costly implications of metadata breakages and complexities across the research lifecycle:

  • Researchers: There was overwhelming consensus among stakeholders that researchers shoulder a significant administrative burden to assert or re-assert data (e.g., institution affiliation, funder ID), ultimately disrupting and delaying scientific discovery.
  • Institutions: Because of metadata inconsistencies throughout the research lifecycle, institutions deploy labor-intensive workarounds to manually reconcile funding eligibility and APC billing, as well as normalize unstructured data across disparate systems for comprehensive analysis.
  • Funders: Missing metadata (e.g., registered grant DOIs, institution affiliation) makes it difficult and costly to link funding to research outputs, presenting potential barriers to open access uptake, problematic impact tracking, and incomplete analysis to inform future investments.
  • Publishers: Metadata breakages interfere with business transformation initiatives, contributing to high operational and opportunity costs and complicating fulfillment of open access agreement terms and analysis of deal performance to inform future decisions.

Many stakeholders we interviewed recognize that new metadata strategies, inclusive policies, and a robust framework of interoperable systems are essential for modernizing this element of scholarly communications. It’s also clear that an ecosystem-wide commitment to improving data quality across all groups will facilitate the transition to open while helping to preserve research integrity, expand discoverability, and improve impact measurement. If the industry works collectively to shrink these gaps by reexamining metadata policy and practice, stakeholders will undoubtedly feel less pain. Or, we can continue the current system of entropy, friction, and frustration. Together, we can decide our path.

Topic: Research & Development | Scholarly Communications

Author: Roy Kaufman

  • Connect with Roy Kaufman on LinkedIn
Roy Kaufman is Managing Director of both Business Development and Government Relations for CCC. He is a member of, among other things, the Bar of the State of New York, the Author’s Guild, and the editorial board of UKSG Insights. Kaufman also advises the US Government on international trade matters through membership in International Trade Advisory Committee (ITAC) 13 – Intellectual Property and the Library of Congress’s Copyright Public Modernization Committee. He serves on the Executive Committee of the of the United States Intellectual Property Alliance (USIPA) Board. He was the founding corporate Secretary of CrossRef, and formerly chaired its legal working group. He is a Chef in the Scholarly Kitchen and has written and lectured extensively on the subjects of copyright, licensing, open access, artificial intelligence, metadata, text/data mining, new media, artists’ rights, and art law. Kaufman is Editor-in-Chief of "Art Law Handbook: From Antiquities to the Internet" and author of two books on publishing contract law. He is a graduate of Brandeis University and Columbia Law School.

Author: Jamie Carmichael

  • Connect with Jamie Carmichael on LinkedIn
Jamie Carmichael brings 20 years’ experience in publishing to her current role as Senior Director, Information & Content Solutions, at CCC. In this position, she leads go-to-market strategy for CCC’s open access portfolio, including RightsLink for Scientific Communications and OA Intelligence.

Author: Jessica Thibodeau

  • Connect with Jessica Thibodeau on LinkedIn
Jessica Thibodeau is Senior Director, Information & Content Solutions at CCC. In this position, she is responsible for the strategic direction of CCC’s Ringgold portfolio and go-to-market efforts for products and services across the scholarly communications ecosystem.

For inquiries related to this blog, email blog@copyright.com or follow and connect on LinkedIn to join the conversation.

Post navigation

Previous post

4 Foundational Copyright Tips for Medical Communications Professionals

24 May 2023

Next post

businessman explaining graphs to the rest of his colleagues

Sustainable Business Models Analysis

31 May 2023

Don't miss a post

Subscribe to the award-winning
Velocity of Content blog

Subscribe
Connect with Copyright Clearance Center on LinkedIn Subscribe to Copyright Clearance Center's YouTube Channel Follow Copyright Clearance Center on Facebook Subscribe to Copyright Clearance Center's RSS Feed
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Materials available on copyright.com are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other countries.

© 1995–2025 Copyright Clearance Center, Inc.