Skip to content
Copyright Clearance Center - Copyright & Licensing Experts
  • Get permissions & content
  • Request a demo
  • Get help
  • Log in
    • CCC Marketplace
    • RightFind Enterprise
    • RightFind Navigate
    • RightsLink Permissions
    • Rightsholder Accounts
    • Ringgold Identify Database
    • Institutional Portal
  • Solutions

    • Business
    • Publishing
    • Academia
    • Standards

    Solutions for Business: Overview

    • RightFind Suite Software
      Robust software solutions to fuel scientific research and simplify copyright compliance
    • RightFind Navigate
      Personalized search of scientific content across internal and external data sources
    • RightFind Enterprise
      STM literature management and document delivery
    • RightFind XML
      Licensed article collections for full-text data mining
    • Document Delivery with RightFind
      One-stop journal article ordering and fulfillment
    • RightFind Cite It
      Simplified reference management software
    • CCC Expert View
      Knowledge graphs to ID key opinion leaders
    • Copyright Licensing
      Enterprise-wide content licensing solutions with millions of rights from thousands of publishers
    • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
      Harmonized content collaboration and reuse rights for US-based employees
    • Multinational Copyright License (MCL)
      Extending license coverage to employees around the world
    • Information Services
      Making content and development workflows more discoverable and efficient
    • Deep Search Solutions
      Targeted data gathered, analyzed, and delivered from a range of online sources
    • Reprints & Permissions Services
      Fulfillment of bulk medical/scientific article reprints, ePrints, and permissions
    • Managed Knowledge Services
      Library and information management staffing services
    • CCC Marketplace
      Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in medcomms & business

    Solutions for Publishing: Overview

    • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
      Innovative, metadata-driven solutions to help publishers scale and optimize their transforming business
    • RightsLink for Scientific Communications
      Open Access funding and payment workflow solution
    • OA Intelligence
      AI-enabled data disambiguation, agreement modeling, and analysis software
    • Ringgold Solutions
      Organization persistent identifier (PID) solution and services
    • RightsLink Author Services
      Automated services to expand publication and promotional offerings in author workflows
    • Data Solutions & Services
      Data intelligence and disambiguation solutions and expertise to inform business strategy
    • Ringgold Identify Database
      Leading curated database of organization persistent identifiers (PIDs)
    • Ringgold Audit Service
      Expert data normalization, enrichment and mapping to Ringgold Identify Database
    • Ringgold Validate Service
      On-demand service to create new Ringgold Organization IDs
    • Ringgold Consortium Directory
      Comprehensive database of up-to-date global consortia records
    • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
      Copyright licenses and transactional services to help publishers expand markets and secure copyright permissions
    • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
      Voluntary collective licenses to compensate publishers for the reuse of their content
    • CCC Marketplace
      Transactional copyright permissions to enable content reuse in published materials
    • Get It Now
      Single article fulfillment of publisher content for higher education
    • Document Delivery with RightFind
      Single article fulfillment of publisher content for businesses
    • Reprints Services for Publishers
      Full-service management of bulk article reprints and ePrints business

    Solutions for Academia: Overview

    • Content & Licensing Solutions
      Content search, discovery, licensing, and fulfillment
    • RightFind Curriculum
      Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 curriculum and instruction
    • Annual Copyright License for Student Assessments
      Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 student assessments, item banks, and pre-and post-test materials.
    • Get It Now
      Cost-effective, integrated 24/7 full-text academic article fulfillment from non-subscribed journals
    • Copyright Licensing
      Annual and transactional licensing solutions for the reuse of copyrighted content in academia
    • Annual Copyright License for Higher Education (ACLHE)
      Rights to reuse and share content across your institution
    • CCC Marketplace
      Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in higher education
    • Copyright Education
      Complimentary webcasts and certificate courses to help navigate copyright and content use in education
    • Copyright Essentials for K-12 Certificate Course
      Foundations of copyright law and its impact on K-12 education
    • Copyright 101 for Academia Certificate Course
      Foundations of copyright law and its impact in higher education
  • Resources

    • Resource Library
      Access recordings, customer success stories, white papers, blog posts, and insights by industry experts.
    • Case studies
    • Communities
    • Videos
    • White papers
    • Insights
    • Blog posts
    • Copyright Education
      Learn about copyright protection, international principles, and best practices for licensing.
    • Copyright foundations
    • International copyright
    • Certificate courses
    • Complimentary webcasts
    • Upcoming Events
      Browse our calendar of webcasts, conferences, presentations, and education programs.
    • Webcasts
    • Conferences
    • Copyright education
    • Media Center
      View the latest CCC news, press coverage, and trending posts on the Velocity of Content blog.
    • Velocity of Content blog
    • CCC In the News
    • Press releases
    • Company
      Learn more about our organization, explore career opportunities, and meet the executive team
    • About CCC
    • Careers & Community
    • Executive Leadership
    • Board of Directors
    • International Advancement
    • Partner Program
  • Solutions
  • Business
    • Overview
    • RightFind Suite Software
      • RightFind Suite Software
        Robust software solutions to fuel scientific research and simplify copyright compliance
      • RightFind Navigate
        Personalized search of scientific content across internal and external data sources
      • RightFind Enterprise
        STM literature management and document delivery
      • RightFind XML
        Licensed article collections for full-text data mining
      • Document Delivery with RightFind
        One-stop journal article ordering and fulfillment
      • RightFind Cite It
        Simplified reference management software
      • CCC Expert View
        Knowledge graphs to ID key opinion leaders
    • Copyright Licensing
      • Copyright Licensing
        Enterprise-wide content licensing solutions with millions of rights from thousands of publishers
      • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
        Harmonized content collaboration and reuse rights for US-based employees
      • Multinational Copyright License (MCL)
        Extending license coverage to employees around the world
    • Information Services
      • Information Services
        Making content and development workflows more discoverable and efficient
      • Deep Search Solutions
        Targeted data gathered, analyzed, and delivered from a range of online sources
      • Reprints & Permissions Services
        Fulfillment of bulk medical/scientific article reprints, ePrints, and permissions
      • Managed Knowledge Services
        Library and information management staffing services
      • CCC Marketplace
        Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in medcomms & business
  • Publishing
    • Overview
    • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
      • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
        Innovative, metadata-driven solutions to help publishers scale and optimize their transforming business
      • RightsLink for Scientific Communications
        Open Access funding and payment workflow solution
      • OA Intelligence
        AI-enabled data disambiguation, agreement modeling, and analysis software
      • Ringgold Solutions
        Organization persistent identifier (PID) solution and services
      • RightsLink Author Services
        Automated services to expand publication and promotional offerings in author workflows
    • Data Solutions & Services
      • Data Solutions & Services
        Data intelligence and disambiguation solutions and expertise to inform business strategy
      • Ringgold Identify Database
        Leading curated database of organization persistent identifiers (PIDs)
      • Ringgold Audit Service
        Expert data normalization, enrichment and mapping to Ringgold Identify Database
      • Ringgold Validate Service
        On-demand service to create new Ringgold Organization IDs
      • Ringgold Consortium Directory
        Comprehensive database of up-to-date global consortia records
    • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
      • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
        Copyright licenses and transactional services to help publishers expand markets and secure copyright permissions
      • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
        Voluntary collective licenses to compensate publishers for the reuse of their content
      • CCC Marketplace
        Transactional copyright permissions to enable content reuse in published materials
      • Get It Now
        Single article fulfillment of publisher content for higher education
      • Document Delivery with RightFind
        Single article fulfillment of publisher content for businesses
      • Reprints Services for Publishers
        Full-service management of bulk article reprints and ePrints business
  • Academia
    • Overview
    • Content Solutions
      • Content & Licensing Solutions
        Content search, discovery, licensing, and fulfillment
      • RightFind Curriculum
        Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 curriculum and instruction
      • Annual Copyright License for Student Assessments
        Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 student assessments, item banks, and pre-and post-test materials.
      • Get It Now
        Cost-effective, integrated 24/7 full-text academic article fulfillment from non-subscribed journals
    • Copyright Licensing
      • Copyright Licensing
        Annual and transactional licensing solutions for the reuse of copyrighted content in academia
      • Annual Copyright License for Higher Education (ACLHE)
        Rights to reuse and share content across your institution
      • CCC Marketplace
        Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in higher education
    • Copyright Education
      • Copyright Education
        Complimentary webcasts and certificate courses to help navigate copyright and content use in education
      • Copyright Essentials for K-12 Certificate Course
        Foundations of copyright law and its impact on K-12 education
      • Copyright 101 for Academia Certificate Course
        Foundations of copyright law and its impact in higher education
  • Standards
  • Resources
    • Resource Library
      • Resource Library
        Access recordings, customer success stories, white papers, blog posts, and insights by industry experts.
      • Case studies
      • Communities
      • Videos
      • White papers
      • Insights
      • Blog posts
    • Copyright education
      • Copyright Education
        Learn about copyright protection, international principles, and best practices for licensing.
      • Copyright foundations
      • International copyright
      • Certificate courses
      • Complimentary webcasts
    • Upcoming Events
      • Upcoming Events
        Browse our calendar of webcasts, conferences, presentations, and education programs.
      • Webcasts
      • Conferences
      • Copyright education
    • Media Center
      • Media Center
        View the latest CCC news, press coverage, and trending posts on the Velocity of Content blog.
      • Velocity of Content blog
      • CCC In the News
      • Press releases
  • Company
    • Company
      Learn more about our organization, explore career opportunities, and meet the executive team
    • About CCC
    • Careers & Community
    • Executive Leadership
    • Board of Directors
    • International Advancement
    • Partner Program
  • Get permissions & content
  • Request a demo
  • Get help
  • Log in
    • CCC Marketplace
    • RightFind Enterprise
    • RightFind Navigate
    • RightsLink Permissions
    • Rightsholder Accounts
    • Ringgold Identify Database
    • Institutional Portal

Velocity of Content

Home Blog Research & Development Identifiers, Metadata, and Shared Infrastructures Bolster Research Integrity

Identifiers, Metadata, and Shared Infrastructures Bolster Research Integrity

By Andrea Chiarelli
4 January 2024

Share this post
facebooklinkedinmail

This piece originally appeared in Research Information. Re-published with permission.

With the Retraction Watch database hitting almost 50,000 items and an ever-growing number of high-profile research misconduct cases, questions around the veracity of published research findings are becoming uncomfortably common. Verifying the accuracy of published research is a meticulous and rigorous process. Today, this requires painstaking and mostly manual work, although technology is rapidly coming to the rescue: following decades of digital research infrastructure development, we can start to imagine a future where humans and machines can work together to validate the public record and help corroborate its trustworthiness.

Away from the spotlight of groundbreaking discoveries and intellectual discourse lie some of the unsung heroes of research: persistent identifiers, metadata and shared infrastructures. These silent forces can bolster research integrity, ensuring traceability and attribution, discouraging plagiarism and promoting responsible research and innovation practices.

In this article, we highlight how the tools we have grown accustomed to are quietly underpinning research integrity and helping to foster a culture of transparency and trust.

Enhancing accessibility, credibility and transparency in scholarly communication

Persistent identifiers are indispensable in scholarly communication, and examples include Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs) for research objects, ORCID iDs for individuals, International Standard Name Identifier (ISNIs) for contributors to creative works and those active in their distribution and Research Organizations Registry (ROR) or Ringgold IDs for organizations. Today, DOIs are the most widespread form of persistent identifier in the academic publishing landscape and serve as permanent markers for digital resources: they connect users and machines to content, no matter where this is physically hosted, and they ensure its availability regardless of location changes due to platform shifts or system architecture updates. This not only supports the long-term preservation of research objects but also their future accessibility.

Meanwhile, identifiers for individuals and organizations help in augmenting the transparency and credibility of published works, for example by flagging that an output is linked with authors from one or more research organizations or has been supported by a specific funder. The use of identifiers for peer reviewers has historically been less common but is starting to rise up the agenda in light of growing numbers of misconduct cases involving peer review manipulation. As Kim Eggleton – Head of Peer Review & Research Integrity, IOP Publishing puts it: “Our industry has been built on trust, but with paper mills now a sad reality for all of us, we can’t continue to rely on trust alone. We need a better record of what was created, how and by whom, plus how it has changed over time.”

Metadata complements the use of persistent identifiers and provides the necessary context and understanding for the reuse of digital research objects over time. It contains insights into how a given research object was obtained or generated and facilitates its correct interpretation and meaningful application. In some cases, scholarly metadata is also used to describe each author’s specific contribution to the output, for example through CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy), which can further characterize the provenance of a research object.

Independent consultant Haseeb Irfanullah said: “As an editor, it is very difficult to identify whether all the authors have contributed to an article. Even if I asked them directly, how could I check?”

Shared scholarly infrastructures can take a variety of shapes, but their main role is to act as a bridge between persistent identifiers, metadata, and research objects. Metadata flowing between digital infrastructures can also communicate and surface information on retractions, expressions of concern or correction notices, which are essential to understand when and why the scholarly record has been modified.

Additionally, enhancing the connectivity between research objects and metadata across different systems can also have a positive impact on reproducibility, meaning the ability to duplicate the results of a study using the same methods and data as were used in the original investigation. If a researcher can not only access research objects – a matter of discoverability and openness – but also understand them – which stems from complete and accurate metadata – they will be far better placed to try and reproduce the results in question.

Hylke Koers – Chief Information Officer, STM Solutions, said: “Well-executed infrastructure has the potential to help researchers find, access, quote and reuse information that is scattered across the web and different content sources, in a way that is easy to navigate and interoperable.”

From mitigation to prevention: the importance of trust and interoperability

Interoperability is the ability of different systems, devices, applications and products to connect and communicate in a coordinated way, without effort from the end user. In the case of scholarly communication infrastructures, this can be enabled by adopting identifiers that describe individuals, organizations and research objects. With different infrastructures working in unison, regardless of data provenance, we can promote a more integrated digital ecosystem where suspicious behaviors or information can be surfaced and brought to the attention of research stakeholders.

Laura Cox, Senior Director, Publishing Industry Data, at Copyright Clearance Center, said: “Interoperable metadata attached to research objects can be used to inform the detection of suspicious patterns and to develop early warning signs of potential misconduct.”

In this context, the reliability and trustworthiness of (meta)data should not be overlooked. It is not enough for information to be complete and interoperable; it must also be accurate and reliable. The challenge for research integrity professionals lies in discerning what information is reliable and which is not. In practice, poorly collected or incorrectly linked data can lead to misleading assumptions and conclusions, causing more harm than good.

Sabina Alam, Director of Publishing Ethics and Integrity, Taylor and Francis Group, explained: “As part of research integrity checks, we may find the same ethical approval or funding reference number in absolutely unconnected papers. And this is difficult to address because verifying whether these are even real, in a quick and scalable way, is not always possible.”

Tools based on artificial intelligence can leverage high-quality and trusted (meta)data to facilitate human decision-making, for example in emerging use cases such as the automated detection of research outputs associated with paper mills. Thanks to advancements in machine learning and knowledge graphs, exemplified by initiatives like the Open Research Knowledge Graph, and increased information sharing within the sector through platforms like the STM Integrity Hub, we are witnessing fast-improving capabilities to automatically identify and scrutinize potential misconduct on a scale that was previously unattainable.

Recognizing the power of trusted persistent identifiers, metadata and shared infrastructures

Metadata, persistent identifiers and robust digital infrastructures, though not always visible on the surface, form the bedrock of research integrity. As discussed above, however, taking action around research integrity also requires metadata and infrastructures that can be trusted, plus an extent of collaboration between scholarly actors.

To maximize the potential of these silent enablers of research integrity, all research stakeholders can take several steps:

  • Invest in robust and trusted systems which use data quality frameworks and metrics, supported by validation to manage and standardize metadata and PIDs, ensuring consistency and ease of data exchange;
  • Prioritize training and education around the importance of these elements, including highlighting their impact on research integrity; and
  • Exchange knowledge and best practices with peer organizations, championing the creation and use of complete and interoperable information and tearing down barriers to sharing and reuse.

The rising complexity of the scholarly ecosystem, coupled with the transformative potential of emerging technologies such as artificial intelligence, demand a clear commitment for robust metadata, persistent identifiers and digital infrastructures from all individuals and organizations involved in research. The steps we take today to invest in and enhance these foundational elements will shape the future integrity and trustworthiness of our collective knowledge and pave the way for advancements in understanding and improving our world.

Topic: Research & Development | Scholarly Communications

Author: Andrea Chiarelli

Dr. Andrea Chiarelli is a Principal Consultant at Research Consulting, a mission-driven business working to improve the effectiveness and impact of research and scholarly communication.

For inquiries related to this blog, email blog@copyright.com or follow and connect on LinkedIn to join the conversation.

Post navigation

Previous post

Man in a business meeting using an interactive screen while giving a presentation

Ringgold and the FAIR Principles: How Ringgold Data and Metadata are Findable 

3 January 2024

Next post

graphic illustration of a man using a magnifying globe to see Data on the earth

Research & The Real World

8 January 2024

Don't miss a post

Subscribe to the award-winning
Velocity of Content blog

Subscribe
Connect with Copyright Clearance Center on LinkedIn Subscribe to Copyright Clearance Center's YouTube Channel Follow Copyright Clearance Center on Facebook Subscribe to Copyright Clearance Center's RSS Feed
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Materials available on copyright.com are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other countries.

© 1995–2025 Copyright Clearance Center, Inc.