Skip to content
Copyright Clearance Center - Copyright & Licensing Experts
  • Get permissions & content
  • Request a demo
  • Get help
  • Log in
    • CCC Marketplace
    • RightFind Enterprise
    • RightFind Navigate
    • RightsLink Permissions
    • Rightsholder Accounts
    • Ringgold Identify Database
    • Institutional Portal
  • Solutions

    • Business
    • Publishing
    • Academia
    • Standards

    Solutions for Business: Overview

    • RightFind Suite Software
      Robust software solutions to fuel scientific research and simplify copyright compliance
    • RightFind Navigate
      Personalized search of scientific content across internal and external data sources
    • RightFind Enterprise
      STM literature management and document delivery
    • RightFind XML
      Licensed article collections for internal AI projects
    • Document Delivery with RightFind
      One-stop journal article ordering and fulfillment
    • RightFind Cite It
      Simplified reference management software
    • CCC Expert View
      Knowledge graphs to ID key opinion leaders
    • Copyright Licensing
      Enterprise-wide content licensing solutions with millions of rights from thousands of publishers
    • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
      Harmonized content collaboration and reuse rights
    • AI Systems Training License
      Obtain the rights to use content for training external AI systems—fairly and efficiently
    • Information Services
      Making content and development workflows more discoverable and efficient
    • Deep Search Solutions
      Targeted data gathered, analyzed, and delivered from a range of online sources
    • Reprints & Permissions Services
      Fulfillment of bulk medical/scientific article reprints, ePrints, and permissions
    • Managed Knowledge Services
      Library and information management staffing services
    • CCC Marketplace
      Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in medcomms & business

    Solutions for Publishing: Overview

    • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
      Innovative, metadata-driven solutions to help publishers scale and optimize their transforming business
    • RightsLink for Scientific Communications
      Open Access funding and payment workflow solution
    • OA Intelligence
      AI-enabled data disambiguation, agreement modeling, and analysis software
    • Ringgold
      Leading Persistent Identifier (PID)-based solutions
    • RightsLink Author Services
      Automated services to expand publication and promotional offerings in author workflows
    • PID-Based Data Solutions
      Expertly curated, high-quality data that powers confident, strategic decision-making and enables data interoperability
    • Ringgold Organizations
      Trusted data about global organizations engaged in scholarly research
    • Ringgold Audit Service
      Leverage trusted data experts to normalize and enrich your data
    • Ringgold Validate Service
      New Ringgold IDs created on demand for organizations not in our database
    • Ringgold Consortium Directory
      Comprehensive database of up-to-date global consortia records
    • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
      Copyright licenses and transactional services to help publishers expand markets
    • Licensing Services for Publishers
      Generate new revenues and reach new markets with annual license and transactional services
    • Document Delivery with RightFind
      Single article fulfillment of publisher content for businesses
    • Reprints Services for Publishers
      Full-service management of bulk article reprints and ePrints business

    Solutions for Academia: Overview

    • Content & Licensing Solutions
      Content search, discovery, licensing, and fulfillment
    • RightFind Curriculum
      Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 curriculum and instruction
    • Annual Copyright License for Student Assessments
      Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 student assessments, item banks, and pre-and post-test materials.
    • Copyright Licensing
      Annual and transactional licensing solutions for the reuse of copyrighted content in academia
    • Annual Copyright License for Higher Education (ACLHE)
      Rights to reuse and share content across your institution
    • CCC Marketplace
      Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in higher education
    • Copyright Education
      Complimentary webcasts and certificate courses to help navigate copyright and content use in education
    • Copyright Essentials for K-12 Certificate Course
      Foundations of copyright law and its impact on K-12 education
    • Copyright 101 for Academia Certificate Course
      Foundations of copyright law and its impact in higher education
  • Resources

    • Resource Library
      Access recordings, customer success stories, white papers, blog posts, and insights by industry experts.
    • Case studies
    • Communities
    • Videos
    • White papers
    • Insights
    • Copyright Education
      Learn about AI & copyright, international principles, and best practices for licensing.
    • AI, Copyright & Licensing Community
    • Copyright foundations
    • International copyright
    • Certificate courses
    • Complimentary webcasts
    • Upcoming Events
      Browse our calendar of webcasts, conferences, presentations, and education programs.
    • Webcasts
    • Conferences
    • Copyright education
    • Media Center
      View the latest CCC news, press coverage, and trending posts on the Velocity of Content blog.
    • Velocity of Content blog
    • Featured podcasts
    • CCC In the News
    • Press releases
    • Company
      Learn more about our organization, explore career opportunities, and meet the executive team
    • About CCC
    • Careers & Community
    • Executive Leadership
    • Board of Directors
    • International Advancement
    • Partner Program
  • Solutions
  • Business
    • Overview
    • RightFind Suite Software
      • RightFind Suite Software
        Robust software solutions to fuel scientific research and simplify copyright compliance
      • RightFind Navigate
        Personalized search of scientific content across internal and external data sources
      • RightFind Enterprise
        STM literature management and document delivery
      • RightFind XML
        Licensed article collections for internal AI projects
      • Document Delivery with RightFind
        One-stop journal article ordering and fulfillment
      • RightFind Cite It
        Simplified reference management software
      • CCC Expert View
        Knowledge graphs to ID key opinion leaders
    • Copyright Licensing
      • Copyright Licensing
        Enterprise-wide content licensing solutions with millions of rights from thousands of publishers
      • Annual Copyright License (ACL)
        Harmonized content collaboration and reuse rights
      • AI Systems Training License
        Obtain the rights to use content for training external AI systems—fairly and efficiently
    • Information Services
      • Information Services
        Making content and development workflows more discoverable and efficient
      • Deep Search Solutions
        Targeted data gathered, analyzed, and delivered from a range of online sources
      • Reprints & Permissions Services
        Fulfillment of bulk medical/scientific article reprints, ePrints, and permissions
      • Managed Knowledge Services
        Library and information management staffing services
      • CCC Marketplace
        Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in medcomms & business
  • Publishing
    • Overview
    • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
      • Scholarly Communications Suite Software & Services
        Innovative, metadata-driven solutions to help publishers scale and optimize their transforming business
      • RightsLink for Scientific Communications
        Open Access funding and payment workflow solution
      • OA Intelligence
        AI-enabled data disambiguation, agreement modeling, and analysis software
      • Ringgold
        Leading Persistent Identifier (PID)-based solutions
      • RightsLink Author Services
        Automated services to expand publication and promotional offerings in author workflows
    • Data Solutions & Services
      • PID-Based Data Solutions
        Expertly curated, high-quality data that powers confident, strategic decision-making and enables data interoperability
      • Ringgold Organizations
        Trusted data about global organizations engaged in scholarly research
      • Ringgold Audit Service
        Leverage trusted data experts to normalize and enrich your data
      • Ringgold Validate Service
        New Ringgold IDs created on demand for organizations not in our database
      • Ringgold Consortium Directory
        Comprehensive database of up-to-date global consortia records
    • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
      • Licensing & Content Delivery Services
        Copyright licenses and transactional services to help publishers expand markets
      • Licensing Services for Publishers
        Generate new revenues and reach new markets with annual license and transactional services
      • Document Delivery with RightFind
        Single article fulfillment of publisher content for businesses
      • Reprints Services for Publishers
        Full-service management of bulk article reprints and ePrints business
  • Academia
    • Overview
    • Content Solutions
      • Content & Licensing Solutions
        Content search, discovery, licensing, and fulfillment
      • RightFind Curriculum
        Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 curriculum and instruction
      • Annual Copyright License for Student Assessments
        Content and licensing solution to search for, discover, and incorporate copyrighted content into K-12 student assessments, item banks, and pre-and post-test materials.
    • Copyright Licensing
      • Copyright Licensing
        Annual and transactional licensing solutions for the reuse of copyrighted content in academia
      • Annual Copyright License for Higher Education (ACLHE)
        Rights to reuse and share content across your institution
      • CCC Marketplace
        Transactional copyright permissions to reuse content in higher education
    • Copyright Education
      • Copyright Education
        Complimentary webcasts and certificate courses to help navigate copyright and content use in education
      • Copyright Essentials for K-12 Certificate Course
        Foundations of copyright law and its impact on K-12 education
      • Copyright 101 for Academia Certificate Course
        Foundations of copyright law and its impact in higher education
  • Standards
  • Resources
    • Resource Library
      • Resource Library
        Access recordings, customer success stories, white papers, blog posts, and insights by industry experts.
      • Case studies
      • Communities
      • Videos
      • White papers
      • Insights
    • Copyright education
      • Copyright Education
        Learn about AI & copyright, international principles, and best practices for licensing.
      • AI, Copyright & Licensing Community
      • Copyright foundations
      • International copyright
      • Certificate courses
      • Complimentary webcasts
    • Upcoming Events
      • Upcoming Events
        Browse our calendar of webcasts, conferences, presentations, and education programs.
      • Webcasts
      • Conferences
      • Copyright education
    • Media Center
      • Media Center
        View the latest CCC news, press coverage, and trending posts on the Velocity of Content blog.
      • Velocity of Content blog
      • Featured podcasts
      • CCC In the News
      • Press releases
  • Company
    • Company
      Learn more about our organization, explore career opportunities, and meet the executive team
    • About CCC
    • Careers & Community
    • Executive Leadership
    • Board of Directors
    • International Advancement
    • Partner Program
  • Get permissions & content
  • Request a demo
  • Get help
  • Log in
    • CCC Marketplace
    • RightFind Enterprise
    • RightFind Navigate
    • RightsLink Permissions
    • Rightsholder Accounts
    • Ringgold Identify Database
    • Institutional Portal

Velocity of Content

Home Blog Data Management Ringgold and the FAIR Principles: How Ringgold Data and Metadata are Reusable
Paperwork and group of peoples hands on a board room table at a business presentation or seminar.

Ringgold and the FAIR Principles: How Ringgold Data and Metadata are Reusable

By Laura Cox
24 January 2024

Share
  • Share to LinkedIn
  • Share via Email

The FAIR Principles are vital to enabling the use of data, not just for people, but more importantly for machines. The FAIR principles are designed to address the necessary steps to make research data and the metadata attached to it FAIR (Findable, Accessible, Interoperable, and Reusable).

FAIR enables the use of data and metadata for a wide range of use cases and without it, data is not consumable in a way that is needed to build upon research, to make it reproducible, or to provide it as a trusted source of verified information to new technologies such as artificial intelligence. While the principles were not specifically designed to be applied to metadata schema, or not in isolation, this 4-part blog series will address each of the interlinked FAIR principles and, how Ringgold Data is FAIR Data for organization identification.

The fourth post in our series explores how Ringgold data and metadata are Reusable.

Reusable

The ultimate goal of FAIR is to optimize the reuse of data. To achieve this, metadata and data should be well-described so that they can be replicated and/or combined in different settings. 

R1. (Meta)data are richly described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes

Ringgold Data is fully tagged and labelled, including descriptive elements, and documentation. Metadata is provided independent of use case and clients decide on their own the utility of a given piece of metadata and how it may be used in their authorized systems. External data is only provided if under a clear open license or with full permission to release the data. Variability in data is clearly marked both within the data itself and all documentation with clear vocabularies. This enables interactions between systems and use cases across the scholarly research workflow. 

R1.1. (Meta)data are released with a clear and accessible data usage license

Ringgold IDs are effectively in the public domain, e.g., in JATS and PubMed data, although are not released under a specific license attached to the data. All other Ringgold Data is provided under license with clear authorization for onward transfer, enabling clients and users to utilize the data for use cases that enable Ringgold data to become part of the scholarly record. 

R1.2. (Meta)data are associated with detailed provenance

Where Ringgold Data contains data owned or controlled by another party, it is clearly labelled as external metadata and named using the owning parties naming convention. All Ringgold proprietary data is researched internally and transformed to Ringgold standards for naming, taxonomies, and ontologies.

R1.3. (Meta)data meet domain-relevant community standards

Ringgold Data is used in domain relevant community standards for metadata such as JATS and other NISO standards. It also includes ISO 27729 standard ISNI IDs for the identification of public identities of parties in the media content industries.

Comprehensive Data Management: Beyond FAIR Principles

When thinking about data we should also consider other data principles in addition to FAIR, including but not limited to systems and data security such as SOC2 and ISO standards certification, privacy standards including application of all national and regional legislation and best practices, and best practices around business models and sustainability to ensure the longevity of data access. Not least we should consider data quality and apply metrics in the form of dimensions of data appropriate to the context and develop certificates of data quality.

While “quality issues are not addressed by the FAIR principles,” for over 20 years, publishers have relied on the excellence of Ringgold data. All records in the Ringgold Identify Database are created, maintained and quality-controlled by a team of data experts. This data maintenance is done in accordance with rigorous, up-to-date editorial policies, and changes are structured, tracked, and made available within the dataset. CCC adheres to best practices for data quality, security, and compliance. Ringgold Solutions provides a robust, sustainable solution that continues to evolve with the industry.   

Learn about how Ringgold data and metadata is Findable. 

Learn about how Ringgold data and metadata are Accessible.  

Learn about how Ringgold data and metadata are Interoperable.  

Topic: Data Management | Scholarly Communications

Author: Laura Cox

  • Connect with Laura Cox on LinkedIn
Laura Cox is the Senior Director, Publishing Industry Data at CCC. Subsequent to CCC's acquisition of Ringgold she has a broader remit of providing leadership in product offerings and operational excellence related to data, with a particular focus on scholarly publishing. She remains active in Ringgold’s outward facing activities. She sits on the ISNI Board and on steering committees in the scholarly communications environment. She was a publishing consultant for ten years, working with a variety of international clients including publishers, intermediaries and trade associations. Laura has extensive experience in strategic decision making, consultancy, data analysis, and management. She created the Consortium Directory Online which was acquired by Ringgold, along with her consulting business, in September 2011.

For inquiries related to this blog, email blog@copyright.com or follow and connect on LinkedIn to join the conversation.

Post navigation

Previous post

Search Engine Optimization

RightFind XML Named Best in Show at Bio-IT World Europe

18 January 2024

Next post

illustration of AI

Is AI’s Copyright World Flat, or Will AI Flatten the Copyright World?

25 January 2024

Don't miss a post

Subscribe to the award-winning
Velocity of Content blog

Subscribe
Connect with Copyright Clearance Center on LinkedIn Subscribe to Copyright Clearance Center's YouTube Channel Follow Copyright Clearance Center on Facebook Subscribe to Copyright Clearance Center's RSS Feed
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Materials available on copyright.com are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other countries.

© 1995–2026 Copyright Clearance Center, Inc.